The media, policymakers and even those in the industry have let evacuated tubes languish as a mere cousin to solar electric.


Michael Humphreys | Apricus

EarthToys Renewable Energy Article
The media, policymakers and even those in the industry have let evacuated tubes languish as a mere cousin to solar electric. 

The Future of Evacuated Tube Technology

By Michael Humphreys, CEO Apricus

In the North American marketplace, solar thermal – and particularly evacuated tube technology – is currently facing an uphill battle for adoption and recognition.  Consumers in the market have embraced photovoltaic technologies, what many would refer to as the ‘sexier’ of the common solar technologies, but have largely overlooked the many factors that make evacuated tube systems a prime choice for the moderate climates of North America and the many innovative emerging applications of solar thermal energy.

When looking to the future of solar thermal applications - hydronic space heating, hot tubs, saunas, and of course domestic hot water are only the applications that have seen widespread adoption so far.  Wit  h solar thermal dehumidification and absorption cooling on the horizon among a number of other potential functions, the increased operating temperatures created by evacuated tubes will be the technology of choice for these new applications.  Evacuated tube collectors are uniquely designed to satisfy the additional demand for heat these loads require.

With all this in mind, it is even more perplexing that consumers and businesses have generally shied away from investing in evacuated tube technology.  Evacuated tubes take up only about one tenth of the space of a comparable PV system and run about a quarter of the price in the majority of cases.  Finally, an evacuated tube system can reach efficiency levels of up to 75% because their tube design creates superior passive tracking whereas PV systems, even at peak performance, often fall short of 20%.

So what has been holding evacuated tubes back?  How can a cost- and environmentally-conscious consumer ignore the quicker rate of return and increased efficiency in absorption and usage of solar energy still opt for a photovoltaic system? 

The answers are prominence and production.

Prominence we have addressed in part above.  Popular media has been quick to embrace photovoltaic technology and its vast potential, and there is little argument against the fact that PV technology will be an integral part of the future of the world’s renewable energy mix.

But the media, policymakers and even those in the industry have let evacuated tubes languish as a mere cousin to solar electric.  It is an effective technology without a champion and even internationally we see the same thing; best demonstrated by the omission of solar thermal from the International Energy Agency (IEA) report to the G8 group of countries published about renewable energy in June 2008.

This is in part because electricity is easy for people to understand and easy to measure.  What is strange though is that electricity consumption, depending on who you ask, only accounts for 20%-30% of our energy requirements, and heating and cooling make up almost double that.  It is clear that more emphasis needs to be placed on the thermal requirements of the market.

But perhaps the simpler explanation is that consumers have a child-like fascination with novelty.  Consumers queue up for hours to have a new iPhone, but would never do the same thing for a proven and reliable standard issue device.  Solar thermal is tried and tested – a hurdle in a market of consumers entranced by the newest shiny things

There are attainable solutions to these dilemmas though, and the burden fortunately or unfortunately falls on those who manufacture and install these systems.  As the marketplace evolves as solar technology as a whole sees a spike in adoption, evacuated tube professionals have to shift the messages that are being delivered to the public.

The days of marketing on marvel – wowing the consumer with the novelty of it all – are behind us.  The next frontier in promoting evacuated systems will turn away from system photographs and statistics about the total square footage installed nationwide to the innovative applications and the benefits it provides the consumer – guilt-free showers and baths, radiant floor and wall heating, and the immense savings and quick payback period.

But as new applications emerge and the prominence of thermal rises, the last hurdle for evacuated tubes becomes apparent, and that is monitoring production.

Solar thermal, unlike PV, is not easy to quantify, and this has traditionally made it harder to meter. Where photovoltaic production is measured simply in kilowatt hours, heat is measured in British Thermal Units (BTUs), and sometimes less desirably in the even more uncertain meters squared of installation. 

The result of this is that these systems are often regarded – at least at the policy and regulation level – as energy saving or energy efficiency systems rather than actual power production.  This lack of metering has been a major hurdle to the inclusion of solar thermal as a source of RECS and has limited its inclusion in other legislation.  And most concerning of all is that when thermal is lumped in with efficiency measures, its price comparison is off the charts and seems unapproachably expensive when compared to double pane windows and spray-on insulation.

The first utility to adopt metering for solar heating in the US marketplace was Lakeland Electric in Florida.  They have established a unique program where Lakeland purchased and installed the thermal systems so that the power provider could generate and collect the RECs produced to sell on the open market while the consumer benefited from reduced heating bills and the ability to purchase the system over time.  The operation was small at first, but has continued to grow over time. 

These types of innovative programs have demonstrated that the ability to properly quantify and standardize reporting for the output of systems is an important factor in continued growth.  Even as legislation is put in place, many older installs do not have any metering system installed, but the regulations should serve as encouragement for customers to invest in monitoring so that they can take advantage of the additional benefit of REC generation, especially as RPS standards continue to become more stringent for utilities.

Until recently, the most reliable measure for performance has simply been the comparing of utility bills month-for-month, year-by-year. This falls way short of the ideal, and makes it nearly impossible for legislators to create programs and incentives that helps promote the energy produced by evacuated tubes because they are not being provided with easy to understand metrics by which solar thermal can be rewarded. 

Measurements provide a clear conclusion about the amount of natural gas or electricity that is being offset for domestic hot water, and meters should be encouraged and installed in as many systems as possible to demonstrate the amount of energy produced.  The difference is simply the measurement unit used, and BTUs of energy are easily translated into kWh for general public and policy-maker consumption – making it easier to recognize and accept across the country.

Increased adoption of standards in installation and monitoring will pave the way for further advancement in legislation and incentives for thermal technologies and encourage further development of innovative applications for thermal energy – propelling evacuated tubes forward in the market. 

But the burden to produce this change falls on all of us in the evacuated tube industry to champion the technology and create increasingly effective systems and packages to meet the evolving expectations of the consumer as well as installers.  It is only then that solar thermal can regain its position as the novel application of solar energy and the first choice when homeowners and businesses choose to go green, an evolved market where evacuated tubes will flourish as the choice for emerging applications.


Comments (0)

This post does not have any comments. Be the first to leave a comment below.

Post A Comment

You must be logged in before you can post a comment. Login now.

Featured Product

WS510 Secondary Standard

WS510 Secondary Standard

In the monitoring of large photovoltaic (Utility Scale), in assessing potential sites (Solar-assessment), or in up and coming electricity cost saving initiatives projects (Commercial & Industrial), the WS510 now provides the market a secondary standard pyranometer, ultrasonic wind speed, ultrasonic wind direction, temperature, pressure and humidity all in a single unit.. This sensor meets the high demands of the world meteorological organization (WMO) through the active valving at air temperature measurement and the inertia- and maintenance-free measurement of wind speed and wind direction on the ultrasonic principle. Equipped with a Kipp & Zonen pyranometer of the secondary standards, the WS510-UMB Compact weather sensor from Lufft unites the precision of a variety of meteorological individual sensors in a single all-in-one device, for the first time.