Scottish Renewables calls for greater transparency on constraint payments

"In the interests of transparency and an open debate about the costs and benefits of all forms of electricity, it is time for the grid operator to publish details of payments to other individual sectors – not just to wind."

In response to recent media reports on the amount paid to wind farm operators not to generate electricity, Scottish Renewables has called for greater transparency over payments to other forms of electricity generation, which are six times greater than payments to wind.


Niall Stuart, Chief Executive of Scottish Renewables, has written to National Grid demanding that the company publish a regular breakdown of payments to all forms of electricity generation, not just wind as is current practice.

Commenting on recent reports which only highlighted payments to wind power, Mr Stuart said: "Wind was responsible for 14% of all constraint payments in the first half of this financial year, with coal, gas and hydro accounting for the vast majority of the other 86%.

"Total constraint payments were equal to £161.2m and the cost of constraining wind was £23.3m, meaning that coal, gas and other generators received £137.9m – six times the amount paid to wind.

"Despite this, National Grid only publishes detailed figures on payments to wind, with no breakdown given for the other sectors.

"In the interests of transparency and an open debate about the costs and benefits of all forms of electricity, it is time for the grid operator to publish details of payments to other individual sectors – not just to wind."

He added: "Constraint payments are an essential part of managing the grid, but the public deserves to know where their money is being spent, and the fact that payments to wind are significantly less than those made to coal and gas generation."

When National Grid is unable to fulfil their contractual obligation of taking electricity from an individual generator they are asked to reduce output or cease operation. The operator is compensated for loss of revenue via constraint payments. This is a routine practice of balancing the grid which needs to meet supply and demand continuously throughout the day.

Recent figures published by the Department of Energy and Climate Change revealed Scottish renewable energy projects generate the equivalent of 40% of our electricity needs; more than either coal or gas.

Featured Product

LG Solar Unveils NeON R with Enhanced Aesthetics and Energy Savings

LG Solar Unveils NeON R with Enhanced Aesthetics and Energy Savings

The NeON R module features "Back Contact" cell technology delivering an entirely black panel that is aesthetically pleasing and energy efficient. The cell's seamless, surface blends perfectly into nearly all rooftop designs while the module's electrodes are positioned on the rear of the cell. Using LG's N-type cell structure, the panels produce 365W of energy, up to 7.3kWp, compared to 5.8kWp of the p-type cell. The module's new design minimizes LID, thereby delivering a longer lifespan and increased energy output.